To find the ingredients, you could do the following:
- By retrieving your unicorn's horn
- By removing your Pegasus' wings
- with the UFOs
- when your horses wake up on their birthdays (maximum 4 per day)
- by taking part in competitions (maximum 4 per day)
- when you find a tub of grease with your horses (maximum 3 per day)
- in Flash Sales
- during your first connection of the day
- in the Horns of Plenty (2 ingredients per Horn of Plenty)
In addition, if you were over the age of 13, you could watch sponsered videos in order to earn more ingredients.
Each time you baked the same recipe, the amount of ingredients needed to complete it tripled. For example, if you needed 2 bowls of sugar to make something, if you made it again, you would need 6 bowls of sugar.